Imposta Webstyler come Pagina Iniziale - Set Webstyler as Home page
Aggiungi Webstyler ai tuoi Preferiti

 

sponsor


Clicca il settore che ti interessa e di cui vuoi vedere la lista degli articoli

SISTEMI OPERATIVI

TREND WEB

MARKETING

WEB WRITING

WEB STYLE

WEB DESIGN

DATABASE

ASP

PHP

Clicca il settore che ti interessa e di cui vuoi vedere la lista dei tutorial

MARKETING

WEB DESIGN

ASP

PHP

Lista Faq

Lista News

FAQ

NEWS

Vota il sondaggio !!!

Cosa manca in questo portale
Sezione Download
Libreria immagini
Libreria icone
Script php - mysql
Interviste web designer
altro (commenta)
iscriviti alla newsletter per ricevere le novità del sito comodamente nella tua casella di posta elettronica

 iscrizione

 cancellazione

La ns galleria dedicata alle opere digitali

VISITA LA GALLERIA DIGITALE

Aiutaci a far crescere Webstyler , collaborare è facile e veloce

COLLABORA 

LOGIN

Clicca per visualizzare tutti i link recensiti

WebGuadagni
Mw Hardware Max
Radio Spazio A4
Manuali.net
Innoland
Wetalk
Sos-Ok.net
AZ
Guarda tutti i link

Clicca per visionare la classifica completa !

Korat Ozturan32856

Fox Comunication4139

Cherry Bomb Press1249
Classifica completa

Chi siamo .:. Cosa facciamo .:. Cosa faremo .:.

CHI SIAMO

CONTATTACI

Inserite le parole da cercare - Il metodo utilizzato di default è l'and , cioé verrano selezionate le pagine che contengono tutti i valori da Voi inseriti

Comunità Virtuale - Entra nel ns Nuovo FORUM !! Oppure in CHAT !!

FORUM

CHAT

 
 
Data : 16-12-2003 Autore : Andrea Mencarini
Tipo : TutorialSettore : marketing
Titolo : Websites Benchmarking: Wal-Mart vs Tesco
     

Website Benchmarking in Retail Industry: Wal-Mart vs. Tesco.

La presente analisi è stata presentata dall'autore alla Strathclyde Business School (UK) all'interno del corso di E-Business & International Marketing.


I have analysed the retailing industry (B2C) comparing Wal-Mart and Tesco.

First of all, I’ve tried to identify some key parameters to evaluate these worldwide players.

I made a 2 step process:
1 – identifying key macro-areas for assessing web-sites (i.e. navigability);
2 – finding specific parameters within each macro-areas (i.e. navigability may be measured in terms of no. of clicks but also time to load pages and so on).


Key areas (and specific parameters) for a useful benchmarking:

- Wed design
o Easy to read (clear wording and structuring)
o Nice colours (pure aesthetics)
o Any video/music (to enhance consumers experience);

- Navigability
o Clear organization of the site (is it straightforward where to click to find a specific piece of info?);
o Time to load pages (it has to judge with web design because animate functions and music take longer to be downloaded);
o No. of clicks to go through any page of the site (is the “3 clicks rule” applied?);
o Search engine (Any search engine?);

- E-commerce
o On-line catalogue (are prices, photos, product ingredients, promotional activities and product-related info present and clear?)
o Order-processing (is fast placing an order? Are order-taking formats simple to fill?)
o Delivery-status (is possible to track delivery status? How?)
o Payments (is there any protection for on-line payments? Are there alternative way to pay, maybe off-line ones?)

- Services
o Touch points/CRM (only a general e-mail or specific e-mails for different problems/issues? Are there further info to get in touch with the company for any info?)

- Extras
o Any further or innovative feature (that enhance the customer experience?)


The above framework has been built using my own knowledge (especially for specific parameters) whereas for the macro-areas, I have followed the guidelines of http://www.netb2b.com.





PARAMETERS WAL-MART TESCO
Web-designOverall speaking, these two players are far from representing best practices concerning web-design. Few colours, no java animations, no mp3/avi music to enhance the purchasing experience.They should look outside their industry to find a good benchmark from whom gather some aesthetic solutions.Wal-mart is slightly better than Tesco. Easy to read: excellent (space is well organized with distinct sections starting from the head of the page; the need of conveying most of the info from the homepage has been perfectly balanced with the need to be easily readable);Colours: good (even though it is not a masterpiece in terms of chromatic solutions, it has several colours whose mix makes the sites enjoyable, easy to read and positively supporting the brand image)Video/Music: below average (no sound and no animated effects – the consumer experience is far from being enjoyable) Easy to read: excellent (same critics made to Wal-Mart)Colours: average (it uses white and blue; too simple and looks cheaper than Wal-Mart; brand image doesn’t seem enhanced by the chromatic solutions; however the overall effect is not negative)Video/Music: below average (same critics made to Wal-mart);
NavigabilityAgain Wal-mart is better than Tesco.Wal-mart is excellent on every parameters (for loading time and organization can be taken as a “best practice” example both within and outside the industry). The same is true for Tesco concerning the organization. Unfortunately, Tesco shows some clear weaknesses (i.e. no search engine). Clear organization: excellent (the heading shows all the major product categories and just on left you can see sub-categories without moving down your mouse)Loading time: excellent (much faster than Tesco)No. of clicks: good 3 clicks to find a specific item (Bruce Springsteen’s latest record) and four to fill the basket.Search engine: excellent (it is placed at the very beginning so easy to see and it allows a quick search as well as a tailored one using a double window) Clear organization: very good (the score is lower than Wal-mart because the consumers have to move down on the page to look for sub-categories)Loading time: average (not very fast; this is quite disappointing considering that Tesco hasn’t used any video/music tools that could justify the waiting!)No. of clicks: goodsame performance of Wal-MartSearch engine: below average (not found)
E-commerceTesco is a little bit better than Wal-Mart thanks to its excellent on-line catalogue.Other features follow e-commerce standard practices. On-line catalogue : very good (comprehensive info)Order-processing: good (the format is the usual one like that used by Amazon; annoying the fact that the speed is compromised by the fact that the sign-in process for new consumers is relatively slow)Delivery-status: good (there is an area for delivery status info)Payments/Security: good (consumers are made aware of the use of their info and above all they can delete their acoount any time; transactions are secured using the SSL (Secure Sockets Layer) technology; it doesn’t allow to pay with other means apart credit cards On-line catalogue: excellent (same as Wal-Mart in term of info but it shows special offers from the very beginning of each product category page)Order-processing: good (same as Wal-Mart)Delivery-status: good (same as Wal-mart)Payments/Security: good (it has all Wal-Mart features)
ServicesAgain Tesco seems better than Wal-Mart. Its touch-points are readily available showing a keen interest and commitment on CRM pratices whereas for Wal-Mart this is an area of surprising weakness. Touch points/CRM: below average(not easy to find “touch-points” to send e-mails)Store Finder: a quick search engine to tell consumers where is the closest Wal-Mart store; Touch points/CRM: excellent (from the homepage you have a link to a page where “touch-points” are divided according to major issues); it could be defined as a “best practice” exampleStore Finder: a quick search engine to tell consumers where is the closest Wal-Mart store;
Extras No particular innovation No particular innovation


I can sum-up the key findings of this competitor benchmarking saying that:

- Wal-Mart shows a higher proficiency than Tesco concerning the technological side on the e-business (better aesthetics, faster speed, excellent web pages layout). However, for most of these aspects (especially aesthetics) Wal-Mart is far from being a “best practice example” outside its industry;
- Tesco is better on most of e-marketing activities (both e-commerce and e-CRM); especially concerning e-CRM can be a rather good benchmark even outside the retailing industry.

torna alla home page

 

v.2.0 - © Copyright 2002-06 Webstyler.it . Tutti i diritti sono riservati.
E' vietata la riproduzione anche parziale

Risoluzione ottimale 1024 x 768 

| info@webstyler.it | webmaster@webstyler.it |